lit_handyman (lit_handyman) wrote,

  • Mood:

HANDYMAN'S HELPER: L. Jagi Lamplighter

Publishing…Huh…What Is It Good For?


By L. Jagi Lamplighter

As children, so many of us dream of becoming authors, of penning some great novel and wowing the world with the vision that flows from our typing fingers. For some of us, this dream comes true…well, at least parts of it come true. Our book actually makes it through the obstacle course of life to the shelves of your local bookstore.

There is a magic to published authors. Like singers or ball players, people have their own idea of what an author’s life might be like. A friend whose wife is an award winning author once told of hearing his teenage daughter’s girlfriend exclaim, “Your mother’s a writer? I didn’t know you were rich!” Once someone is published, we have expectations as to what they must be like.

One of those expectations is that anyone who has entered the publishing wonder world can answer the age old question—the question that is asked again and again, in countless forms—which is better: Big house? Or small press?

Can we?

Well…we can definitely give it a shot.

There are numerous answers to this question. Both forms of publishing have their advantages and disadvantages. The short version, however, is:

Small press: advantage = individual expression; disadvantage = labor of love

Big house: advantage = more money; disadvantage = less creative control.

The longer answer is…longer.


First of all, terms. What is “small press”? What does a “big house” mean?

Small press is any publisher that is not a major publishing interest. Little publishing firms have sprung up all over with the advent of desktop publishing technology. Some of them are fly-by-night. Others are serious concerns. But they are all small by the standards of the numbers of books published when compared to the major New York publishing houses—small in relation to the numbers of books they can provide to the major book chains.

The big houses are the massive publishing concerns, many of which are located in New York City. They produce enormous numbers of books which ship out in large boxes to bookstores all over the country—and sometimes all over the world. Often they are major business conglomerates owned by massive companies that are invested in many types of businesses. For some reason, many of these companies happen to be German. This means that the publishing house’s superiors may not be familiar with the particulars of running a publishing society. Instead, they are concerned with the final bottom line.

The particulars of these two publishing entities lead to their separate strengths and weaknesses.

 Small Press:

Small press publications allows for a great range of creativity. They do not have an enormous conglomerate leaning over their shoulder. Nor do they have the massive overhead of a big publishing house. So long as your writing is decently passable, it is likely that you can find a small press that will publish you.

If you have a project that is in any way out of step with commercial publishing, this can be a great way to go. If you want the work to appear exactly as you want it without someone altering it or editing it. This can be a great way to go. Small presses often allow you a great deal of editorial control over your project.

Another advantage of small press is that the whole process is often faster. There are many small presses to choose from. Their turn around time is often quicker than the big houses. Also, it is often easier to get picked up. Since they seldom pay advances, the small presses can afford to take more chances. They can afford to try new authors.

The difficult side of the small presses is that they print the book, but they do not necessarily get the book in front of the customer. They cannot afford to do large print runs on spec. They prefer to print if they have an order. The number of books they produce is so small that many large chain bookstores will not deal with them.

This means, that, often, it is the author himself who needs to do the work to put his book in front of the customer. For the natural showman, this is not a huge burden. It can be great fun to hawk one’s works at conventions and other appropriate venues. But many writers are solitary, nebbish folks. The idea of talking to people, much less asking them to buy your works, scares them beyond the capacity for rational thought.

Also, any time spent selling one’s books is time not spent writing new ones.

So the advantages of small press are that you can probably get published more quickly and have more control over your work. If for you writing is just a labor of love, this is the way to go! If all you want is to see your mind’s child in print, to show your finished book to your friends and relatives, then this is for you.

The disadvantage is that, unless you really throw your back into the work, this path will bring in little financial gain.

Big Houses:

The big publishing houses, on the other hand, offer a greater financial reward. First, they pay an advance. This is moneys advanced against royalties that the book will theoretically earn. This advance does not need to be paid back as long as the manuscript is delivered as promised, but it is hoped that the book will ‘earn out’ the advance. If it does not, it may be hard to get the publisher to buy your next book.

If you want to make a living writing, the big houses could make that dream possible. You can send off your manuscript and receive in return a check that can actually pay your bills, some of them anyway.

Second, the big houses have a huge leg up on distribution. If you are carried by a big publishing house, your book will probably appear in the big bookstore chains. They can get your book in front of more readers. And they have marketing departments. You don’t have to do everything yourself.

The downside for the big houses is that they are huge concerns looking to make money, and they are paying out money to each author they publish. Hence they are much less willing to take chances. It is much harder for a new author to break in. The track record of an established author is already proven. Why try something new when your German bosses are demanding a healthier bottom line?

Also, they already know what their customers buy. So they often want their next book to look like the last one that did well. Even if they try something new, they may have strong opinions about how the book should read or what should appear on the cover. The author can decide whether to agree to changes to his work, but the look and feel of the book is entirely outside of his control.

So, the big houses pay more, but it is hard to break in to become one of the cherished few, and creative control is lost along the way.

The Personal Touch:

Okay, all this theory is well enough, but what is it really like? What would it feel like for a real person who dealt with both a small and a large publishing company?

Well…it might be a little like this.

Many years ago, in 1992, I started a novel titled, at the time, Prospero’s Children. It was a title I really liked because, while the story was from the point of view of Prospero’s eldest daughter, Miranda, it was really about her whole family—her father and her younger brothers and sisters. I thought the title caught what I wanted to say about the story.

Time went by. I wrote. I put it aside. I wrote it again. Somewhere around 2001, I finished the book and sent it off to my editor, an old boss who worked for a large New York publishing house.

About the same time, maybe a year later, I met Danielle Ackley-McPhail and joined her online writing group.

Time went by. I waited. I waited and I waited.

Danielle and I and some friends decided we would like to put together a small anthology of stories written by members of our writing group. We got fellow members who had a small press company to publish it for us. We picked the stories, got illustrations, picked the cover. The volume was named, aptly, No Longer Dreams.

Meanwhile…when it came to my novel, I waited.

We had so much fun with No Longer Dreams, that Danielle came up with a more ambitious idea. What about a themed anthology where we solicited for new stories? How about one about fairies with attitude. She wanted to call it Bad Ass Faeries.

Meanwhile, I waited….

The Bad Ass Faeries anthologies have come out…three of them now, with a turn around time of about six months. We got to pick the stories, lay them out as Danielle suggested, add pictures we choose, and pick our covers. Everything was just the way we wanted it.

Finally, in 2009, the first volume of my novel, Prospero Lost, finally made it to print. It had taken 8 years, and the cover, while pretty, had nothing to do with the book. In fact, I felt that it gave the wrong kind of idea about what might be inside the cover. Also, the publisher had decided to change Prospero’s Children—as the series name—to Prospero’s Daughter, so that they could put the book in a line called Women In Fantasy. I am grateful for the extra support, but the emphasis on the family, rather than the main character, was lost.

So, w hen it came to creative control, the small press rocked.

On the other hand, the income received from the faery project has been miniscule for me…others who actually go out and hawk the books have made more. While I received a rather nice sized advance for the novel.

So…which one is better? Well, they have both been great! But getting the big house publisher to publish my novel took a tremendous amount of patience, while if I hope to make any money from the faery anthologies, I will have to go out and sell them myself.

And that, folks, is the difference in a nutshell (though why you would want to stuff all that into a nutshell…God only knows. I think it sounds a tad messy.)


Do big house writers make big bucks? Some do. But most of them do not make huge fortunes. However, they do make a good deal more than all but the most intrepid and lucky of small press publishers.

For instance, several genre writers I know make $20,000 to $30,000 a year on average. This includes advances and royalties. The same writers make between $15 and $1000 with their small press projects.

Does a small house mean you will not ever break even? Not at all. Some people put in the hours and days of work hawking their own works and do well by it.

Does a large house mean that your paper baby is definitely going to be mauled? Not at all. My husband just got his latest manuscript back to be copyedited for printing and his editor had not made a single change to it.

So…which type of publishing is for you? That depends upon your preferences and goals. Both can serve admirably…so long as you walk into the experience knowing what to expect.

Which is one answer, at least, to the ancient question of small press vs. big houses. Okay, next question?




Tags: l. jagi lamplighter, major publishers, prospero's daughter, small press, tor

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.